About STP / 877.257.9531
Log In Join Now

Author



Rating

2


Published

Thursday February 1st 2007 1pm

Non-Functional Testing?

Functional Software Testing
There's an interesting discussion going on at the Association For Software Testing discussion list on non-functional testing. Basically, Danny Faught thinks the term is weak and is looking for alternatives. I happen to agree; here's my reply:

Danny Faught Wrote:
>Yes, "non-functional" is a rather bizarre term, though it seems to be gaining acceptance.

Yes, that's kind of a weird term. Personally, I have a problem with "requirements" in most commercial organizations. I have worked in organizations where the requirements process is followed to the letter, the documents are created, and someone comes over to the engineering group and asks "How long will this take to build?"

We reply "Well, as written, about two years. But if you take out bullet points C, F, and G, I can do it by myself in about a month." And, magically, there is a new version of the document with C, F, and G removed.(*)

If that was the case, could we ever really say that C, F, and G were "Required"?

Non-functional testing has the same problem. It is lingo that doesn't -quite- match up with common sense English. Now, I have given up on trying to correct the requirements term; it's just too entrenched. Now, then again eliminating non-functional ... we might have a shot at that.


I like Para-functional.


--Matthew Heusser
(*) - I am exaggerating for effect here.


Comments

You must be logged in to comment.
Retrieving Comments...


Advertisement




Friend SoftwareTestPro on Facebook
Follow @SoftwareTestPro on Twitter
Create or Join a Crew

Tweets You Care About


  • JA_Harrison ( JeanAnn Harrison) @booksrg8 @joolery & @lynn_mckee had a fantastic Keynote at #STPCon in SanDiego #Inspirational Can't help but be passionate about testing
  • Seapine (Seapine Software) Check out Search Software Quality's wrap-up of #STPcon http://t.co/jRTJ4vetYF
  • monkeypunky (nik billings) RT @jerrywelch: Hey @SoftwareTestPro ... Remember that one time ... at #STPCon last week in San Diego? That was pretty cool.
  • lvcodesmith (Scott Scoble) @BrianKCopeland Thanks for your recommendation to attend #stpcon, three of my team went and it was a great conference!
  • cowboytesting (Curtis Stuehrenberg) @jitterted I'll be conducting two sessions at #STPCon. Even if they don't overlap I don't think I can swing two weeks off in the same month
    



Explore STP